Bullion Dealer Comparison
Compare the top online bullion dealers side by side. Premiums, shipping, payment methods, and trust — everything you need to find the best place to buy gold and silver.
Quick Answer
For the lowest premiums on generic silver, compare SD Bullion and JM Bullion first — both offer free shipping over $199 and competitive pricing. APMEX has the widest selection if you need specific products. Always compare the exact product you want across multiple dealers before purchasing.
| Dealer | Founded | Free Shipping | Payment Methods | Selection | Trust Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| JM Bullion | 2011 | Free over $199 | Card, Wire, Check, Crypto | Wide | — |
| SD Bullion | 2012 | Free over $199 | Card, Wire, Check, Crypto | Wide | — |
| APMEX | 2000 | From $9.95 | Card, Wire, Check, PayPal | Largest | — |
| Money Metals Exchange | 2010 | Free over $500 | Card, Wire, Check, Crypto | Moderate | — |
| Provident Metals | 2009 | From $9.95 | Card, Wire, Check | Moderate | — |
| Bold Precious Metals | 2014 | Free over $199 | Card, Wire, Check, Crypto | Moderate | — |
Related Tools & Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best online bullion dealer?
It depends on your priorities. JM Bullion and SD Bullion offer competitive premiums with free shipping over $199. APMEX has the largest selection but slightly higher premiums. Money Metals Exchange offers a monthly savings plan. Compare premiums on the specific products you want to buy.
How do I know if a bullion dealer is trustworthy?
Look for: years in business, BBB rating, customer reviews on Trustpilot and Google, membership in industry organizations, and transparent pricing. All dealers listed here are established businesses with track records of reliable delivery.
Should I pay with credit card or wire transfer?
Wire transfers and checks typically get a 3-4% discount because dealers avoid credit card processing fees. If you're buying a large order, the wire discount can save significant money. Credit cards are convenient for smaller purchases and offer buyer protection.
How much should I pay in premiums?
Generic silver rounds and bars typically carry 5-10% premiums. Government coins like Eagles and Maples are 15-25%. Premiums fluctuate with market conditions — they spike during periods of high demand. Use our Premium Tracker to compare current premiums across dealers.
Get Premium Alerts
Get notified when silver premiums drop to attractive levels with the Silver of Truth app.